Hmmm..... did he go too far? I'm on the fence about this to be honest. I don't think he did but part of me does recognize the bully in him too. This isn't really how you teach children but then I don't know the dynamics of their relationship or what the girl is like otherwise.

That's a tough one.

I'm not huge on punishment as a lesson but sometimes it calls for it? I dunno man.... she still didn't apologize at the time of you writing this so what did that teach her? Nudda....

Good article and good debate too!